Sunday, November 22, 2009

Squash Fundamentalism Wherever it Rears Its Ugly Head

Go for the jugular of fundamentalist mindsets. It is the enemy of freedom of thought. It is plagued by the disease of black-and-white thinking. It divides and often conquers. Yet, fundamentalism is harder to detect than one might realize. It's easy to see it when someone on the Religious Right discriminates against women or gays or promotes a controlling morality based on literalist views of the Bible. It's harder to see when held by progressive secularlists who rightly critique right-wing fundamentalism but succumb to black-and-white thinking in their response.

Years ago I was wrong about atheists. I rejected their world view and their motivation. I wrongly believed they chose to deny God because of their selfish desire to live autonomously in a universe free from moral restraints. I since learned that there are varieties of atheists, just like there are varieties of theists, and many atheists are moral and upright individuals. In fact, one of my heroes these days is an atheist: Ayaan Hirsi Ali, who wrote Infidel, and fights for the rights of Muslim women. But I also learned that some atheists are fundamentalists. Like fundy religionists, they don't fight fair, have an ax to grind, and refuse to go where the evidence leads.

Richard Dawkins, who regularly calls believers delusional, falls in the fundy-atheist category, I would say, along with others among "the new atheists." Atheist Michael Ruse said Dawkin's book, The God Delusion, makes him embarrassed to be an atheist. I respect Ruse for his candor. Antony Flew, the most famous atheist in Europe, changed his position and became a deist. When I read why in his book (There is a God), I gained a new respect for him and his position, even during the time he was an atheist. According to Frank Schaeffer in his new book, Patience with God, atheist Daniel Dennett argues decently and is no fundamentalist. (Dennett, author of Breaking the Spell is one of "the-gang-of-four" new atheists along with Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens, and Sam Harris).

There is such a thing as atheistic fundamentalism. I've learned there is a balanced way to approach religious arguments--in fact any controversial argument--that respects the facts over dogma and always attempts to go where the evidence and one's honest life reflection leads. This leads me to want to squash fundamentalism wherever it rears its ugly head--including inside myself--and pursue this balanced path instead. Care to join me?


snazawa said...

Great post Michael! All of mankind was created in God's image regardless of geographic location, culture, religion, or race and that's why you find people in every single civilized part of this planet who demonstrate sacrificial love. The bottom line is that regardless of what religion or not we ascribe to, evangelicals and Christian fundamentalists are tied together to the rest of the human race because we are all God's children.

While I only believe that reconciliation between God and man comes through Jesus Christ, it's very likely that many Christian fundamentalists will face a harsher judgment in the next age than the atheist who really got love. The fundy Christians love to debate whether Catholic Mother Theresa is saved or not while they personally don't have a clue about sacrifice and love, but they said the sinners prayer at summer camp one night while sitting around a campfire compelled to "accept Jesus" or go to hell!

Josh said...

Yes, I care to join you, but I find it very difficult. I find it difficult to reject the fundamentalism I was a part of (conservative evangelicalism) without doing so very forcefully. And it is a lot easier to be forceful when taking a strong opposite stance. Maybe conveniently so, because the ground you speak of can be more difficult to define and defend, just because it is not the black and white as you note. I just hope I will mellow over time, hmmm, like a fine wine? :^)

Anonymous said...

Amiable fill someone in on and this fill someone in on helped me alot in my college assignement. Thank you for your information.

Anonymous said...

Amiable post and this fill someone in on helped me alot in my college assignement. Thank you for your information.

gothceltgirl said...

This is a fantastic post! I really like how you express your opinions. I too enjoy a good debate, especially about fundamentalism. I was raised in that crazy world. And am so thankful that I managed to escape. As a fellow blogger I hope you check out my blog as well and my site without the 'blog'. I also have another website

DaCosta said...

Excellent post! Fundamentalism is what it is-no matter what stripe. It's amazing that this mindset makes both the religious and athiest fundamentlists more alike than different.